Hello!! This might be one of those situations where the adaptation has conflated with the books for me and I need the advice of an expert. My aunt watched the Ang Lee s&s and asked a great question: Why is it ok with Mrs Ferrars for Robert to marry Lucy but not Edward? Was it the kind of thing where the lie was worse than the actual clandestine engagement? It’s mentioned pretty explicitly that Lucy has no money or status, which we know is an issue. So why is Edward disinherited but Robert not?
"Hi hi!
Firstly I wouldn’t say that it’s Totally Okay with Mrs. Ferrars that Robert marries Lucy. The book does stipulate that they’re somewhat out of favour with Mommie Dearest for some time after their marriage, until eventually Robert and Lucy especially can work their asskissing magic and get them back into Mrs. F’s good graces. Also worth noting that Robert is her favourite son already, for no real sensible reason other than he’s the golden child she decided on.
As Edward says: “She will be more hurt by it, for Robert always was her favourite.—She will be more hurt by it, and on the same principle will forgive him much sooner.”
Part of the ‘joke’ is that Mrs. Ferrars only has two sons, and she’s already disinherited one, so her fortune is settled on Robert. (Which is probably why Lucy’s affections begin to shift.) I don’t think she can disinherit her second son without getting into a legal quagmire over where the family money goes when she dies. (Fanny has presumably had hers as her dowry when she married.) So Lucy outplays Mrs. Ferrars in the game by doing the downright slimiest move and snags Robert and his fortune only after Edward has sacrificed every claim to that fortune for her sake. Mrs. Ferrars has already played all her cards in trying to keep Edward from marrying Lucy, and it looked like she failed. And then she double-failed because Lucy married Robert, instead. And Mrs. Ferrars was so angry in wanting to spite Edward that she arranged things in a manner which means Robert will inherit everything.
Mrs. Ferrars certainly isn’t happy with Lucy and Robert, but Lucy’s powers of ingratiating herself are considerable, and Robert’s already a Mama’s boy, and Mama settled all the inheritance on him, so that’s that.
Elinor does wonder if all this means Fanny will get the whole of the inheritance, now; but this never seems to be a serious threat. Mrs. Ferrars’ disinheriting Edward was meant to induce him to break off the engagement, not to undo a marriage–she can’t use disinheritance to threaten Robert in the same manner, as there was scarcely any engagement to be broken–they just jumped straight to marriage.
Lucy just outplayed absolutely everybody, including Mrs. Ferrars, and Austen gives her her proper due for it:
The whole of Lucy’s behaviour in the affair, and the prosperity which crowned it, therefore, may be held forth as a most encouraging instance of what an earnest, an unceasing attention to self-interest, however its progress may be apparently obstructed, will do in securing every advantage of fortune, with no other sacrifice than that of time and conscience.
Translation: Lucy Steele’s story is proof that you can get away with anything if you well and truly commit to only giving a shit about yourself and absolutely nothing and no-one else.
pizza-hats-of-the-world-1882 liked this morganadasfadasrs liked this
lianfang-zun said:
She paid for being too dramatic. She didn’t have to give Robert anything, and if she really wanted him to inherit, she could have left it in her will, which would be perfectly alterable if she changed her mind later. But nooo, her revenge was more important. She didn’t even have to be a decent person to avoid all this; she would have sufficed to have been prudent. angofwords liked this
themalhambird reblogged this from noburrowingtactics
noburrowingtactics reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
literallyanythingbutmyname liked this
chess-blackfyre reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
chess-blackfyre liked this
beecamila liked this thehobbem liked this
missmakomori liked this
purplecatgarden reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
the-heart-of-the-sun-planet liked this
theamazingfeministunicorn liked this
cmollyo liked this ghost-of-a-dreamer liked this
holygayrightsbatman reblogged this from berdie314
holygayrightsbatman liked this
morgaine2005 reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
morgaine2005 liked this
zephyrantha reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
carpe-mamilia reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
ba66ityra66ity liked this drdone liked this
kungfunurse reblogged this from janeaustentextposts
aslutforequalrights liked this
maraha-k reblogged this from janeaustentextposts rukbat3 liked this
thelastbastionfalls liked this
chocolateinthelibrary liked this
reminiscingwithstrangers liked this gxlden-fox liked this
thatvermilionflycatcher liked this
shefellofftheworld liked this
herskirtsarentthatshort liked this
the-attagirl reblogged this from saraffe
lakedisappointment liked this
coffeeonthelawn liked this
wheredidthe80sgo liked this
yeetoneselfintothevoid liked this shadowcatlovesbooks liked this
ladytremaineposts liked this
koboldspucke liked this
oldfandomlady liked this
lulabo liked this emilyoflanternhill liked this
carpe-mamilia liked this janeaustentextposts posted this
Hello!! This might be one of those situations where the adaptation has conflated with the books for me and I need the...
- Show more notes

